When the Thing You Love Becomes Another Thing to Do
There comes a point every autumn when keeping horses changes character. Summer has its own work, of course, and anyone who has spent an evening trying to persuade a horse that flies are not in fact an existential threat will know that warmer months aren't entirely effortless. But November brings a different sort of labour. The clocks have gone back, daylight has become something you have to plan around, the gateways are beginning their annual descent into mud and everything that was relatively straightforward a few months ago seems to require an additional layer of clothing, organisation and time.

The horses don't appear especially troubled by this. Their winter coats come through, their interest in hay increases and they continue their lives with the enviable certainty that somebody else is responsible for checking the weather forecast. For the humans looking after them, however, winter horse care can begin to feel like a second shift. There are wet rugs to deal with, stables to muck out, water to carry, fields to negotiate and horses who can transform themselves from reasonably clean animals into creatures apparently sculpted from mud during the twenty minutes between being turned out and you returning with the wheelbarrow. You can spend an astonishing amount of time simply maintaining the conditions in which nothing goes wrong.
And still, we love it. That is the part I find interesting, because we're not always very good at allowing love and difficulty to occupy the same space. We have a tendency to believe that the things we choose should not overwhelm us. If we wanted the career, the children, the relationship, the house, the animals or the life we have built, then surely struggling with the demands of it suggests ingratitude. We wanted this. Other people would love to have this. Therefore we should be happy. Except gratitude has never been particularly good at cancelling exhaustion.
You can love your horse and occasionally stand looking at a filthy stable wishing someone else would muck it out. You can feel extraordinarily fortunate to have animals and a life close to the outdoors while also longing for one morning when nothing needs feeding. You can love riding and have periods when getting into the saddle feels like another task on an already impossible list. None of those things tells us very much about how deeply we care. They tell us something about capacity.
This comes up in therapy in all sorts of forms. Somebody loves their job but can no longer sustain what it asks of them. Somebody desperately wanted children and finds parenthood relentless. Someone has willingly taken responsibility for an ageing parent and discovers that compassion doesn't protect them from resentment. A relationship can matter enormously while also requiring more than somebody currently has to give. The problem is often compounded because we don't simply experience the tiredness or frustration; we judge ourselves for having it. The internal conversation becomes something like, I shouldn't feel like this. I chose this. And now we're carrying two things instead of one: the actual demand, and the shame about finding it demanding.
I think horse people can be particularly susceptible to this because the culture around horses contains a fairly robust tradition of getting on with things. Animals need caring for whatever the weather and however you feel. You learn quickly that rain isn't a reason not to go outside, that mud is unavoidable and that plans involving horses are always provisional because the horse retains an absolute right to develop a mysterious swelling, remove a shoe or decline to be caught at precisely the wrong moment.
There is resilience in that, and I value it. But like most strengths, resilience becomes less useful when we lose the ability to choose when to use it. If the answer to every difficulty is push through, eventually we become very good at overriding ourselves. Tired becomes something to ignore. Pain becomes inconvenient. Overwhelm becomes evidence that we need to be more organised. Asking for help feels unnecessary because technically we are still managing. And technically managing can go on for a very long time.
Burnout doesn't always announce itself with a spectacular collapse. Often it looks much more ordinary. We become less patient. Decisions require more effort. Things we used to enjoy begin to feel like obligations. We procrastinate over small tasks, become increasingly irritated by other people's needs or discover that every available scrap of energy is being used to keep the essential parts of life functioning. Sometimes the first thing to disappear is pleasure. That can be frightening when the thing losing its pleasure is something we've always loved.
I've heard people talk about this with work, exercise, friendships, sex, parenting, creativity and all sorts of activities that once gave them something back. With horses it can be particularly visible because the responsibility remains after the desire has temporarily disappeared. You still have to turn up.
It is easy at that point to make the wrong thing the problem. Perhaps I don't love riding anymore. Perhaps I shouldn't have horses. Perhaps I've changed. Perhaps I'm lazy. Perhaps everyone else manages this better than I do. Sometimes those questions deserve consideration. Our lives change, and we're allowed to outgrow things, including things we once loved deeply. But sometimes the horse isn't the problem at all. Sometimes the thing we love has simply become one more place where an exhausted system is being asked to produce energy it no longer has.
That is a very different problem.
One of the things I notice around horses is how much invisible work exists alongside the obvious physical jobs. There is the feed, hay, water and mucking out, but there is also the constant low-level monitoring. When was the farrier? Did I book the dentist? Is there enough hay? Is that leg warmer than the other one? Has she always stood like that? What temperature is it going down to tonight? Which rug? Is the field holding up? When did I last worm count? Why has that horse looked at its stomach twice?
The horse may be peacefully eating while you've already mentally spent three thousand pounds at the veterinary hospital. Responsibility occupies space in the mind even when we're not physically doing anything. The same is true elsewhere. Caring for people involves remembering, anticipating, noticing and organising. Work doesn't necessarily stop occupying us because we've closed the laptop. Difficult relationships continue in conversations we rehearse long after the other person has left the room. For people who are already highly responsible, anxious or inclined to anticipate everybody else's needs, the amount of invisible work being carried can become enormous before anything visibly falls apart.
This is one reason the question Why can't I cope anymore? is often less useful than it first appears.
Capacity isn't a fixed personality trait. It changes. Sleep changes it. Hormones change it. Grief changes it. Stress changes it. Neurodivergence changes how much particular environments cost us. Relationships, health, finances and work all draw from the same finite pool. Something that fitted comfortably into a life five years ago may feel completely different now, not because we've become weaker but because it is no longer the only thing we're carrying. There is a peculiar cruelty in comparing our current capacity with an earlier version of ourselves while ignoring everything that has changed around us. And yet we do it constantly.
I used to manage......Yes. But what else were you carrying then?

This is where I think the stable yard can teach us something useful, although perhaps not the lesson we usually expect from horses. Horses are often talked about as good for mental health, and they certainly can be. Riding can bring us into our bodies. Physical work can interrupt rumination. Caring for another living creature can provide routine, meaning and connection. There are days when walking into the yard changes something in me before I've consciously worked out what needed changing. There are other days when it is simply work. Both are true.
We don't need to romanticise the relationship in order for it to matter. In fact, I think allowing the less picturesque parts into the story makes the relationship more honest. Love that can only exist when something is enjoyable isn't much use across a lifetime. Long relationships of every kind contain periods of boredom, irritation, obligation and effort. What matters is not whether those feelings ever appear, but what they are telling us when they do. Sometimes they tell us that something genuinely needs to change. Sometimes they tell us we're carrying too much. Sometimes they tell us we need help. And sometimes they tell us we need to stop turning everything we care about into another place where we have to perform. That last one can be particularly difficult.
There is always more you could do with horses. Ride more. School better. Clean the tack. Improve the field. Attend the clinic. Book the lesson. Work on the thing you're not very good at. Social media can make it appear that everybody else is riding through golden woodland at sunrise while maintaining immaculate yards, thriving careers and horses whose tails apparently never contain mud. Meanwhile, you have managed to get the field gate open without losing a welly and are considering that a meaningful achievement. It probably is.
There are seasons when enough needs to look different. Perhaps the horse has a day off. Perhaps you ask someone else to turn out. Perhaps the stable doesn't need to be immaculate. Perhaps you don't ride because you don't have enough concentration to ride safely. Perhaps the goal for this winter isn't progress at all. Perhaps it is simply keeping everybody fed, healthy and reasonably sane until the light returns. I don't think lowering the demand is the same thing as lowering our standards. Sometimes it is an intelligent response to reality.
The natural world certainly doesn't maintain the same output throughout the year. By November, the trees have withdrawn resources from their leaves, growth has slowed and energy has moved somewhere less visible. Nothing about the woodland suggests failure. It is responding to conditions.
We seem to expect ourselves to behave differently.
We want summer productivity in winter conditions. We want to maintain work, relationships, caring responsibilities, exercise, social lives, hobbies and homes at exactly the same level regardless of what else is happening, and then we are surprised when something that once gave us pleasure starts feeling like another demand.
Perhaps the answer isn't immediately to remove the thing we love. Perhaps we first ask what has happened around it. What else am I carrying? What has changed? What am I expecting from myself here? Could this relationship survive a season in which I ask less of it?
Those questions feel more generous than What's wrong with me? They also leave room for the possibility that what we need isn't another technique for coping better, but permission to change the terms for a while.
There will be brighter mornings again. The fields will eventually dry, coats will come out in handfuls and one evening we'll realise that there is still enough light to ride after work. The jobs won't disappear, but the balance between what the horses ask of us and what they give back may feel different again.
Until then, there will be November mornings when the thing you love feels remarkably like another thing to do. You can still love it. You can also be tired. There is room for both.

Comments